§2035 — Adjustments for certain gifts made within 3 years of decedent’s death

81 cases·18 followed·20 distinguished·4 criticized·1 limited·6 overruled·32 cited22% support

(a)Inclusion of certain property in gross estate

If—

(1)

the decedent made a transfer (by trust or otherwise) of an interest in any property, or relinquished a power with respect to any property, during the 3-year period ending on the date of the decedent’s death, and

(2)

the value of such property (or an interest therein) would have been included in the decedent’s gross estate under section 2036, 2037, 2038, or 2042 if such transferred interest or relinquished power had been retained by the decedent on the date of his death,

the value of the gross estate shall include the value of any property (or interest therein) which would have been so included.

(b)Inclusion of gift tax on gifts made during 3 years before decedent’s death

The amount of the gross estate (determined without regard to this subsection) shall be increased by the amount of any tax paid under chapter 12 by the decedent or his estate on any gift made by the decedent or his spouse during the 3-year period ending on the date of the decedent’s death.

(c)Other rules relating to transfers within 3 years of death
(1)In general

For purposes of—

(A)

section 303(b) (relating to distributions in redemption of stock to pay death taxes),

(B)

section 2032A (relating to special valuation of certain farms, etc., real property), and

(C)

subchapter C of chapter 64 (relating to lien for taxes),

the value of the gross estate shall include the value of all property to the extent of any interest therein of which the decedent has at any time made a transfer, by trust or otherwise, during the 3-year period ending on the date of the decedent’s death.

(2)Coordination with section 6166

An estate shall be treated as meeting the 35 percent of adjusted gross estate requirement of section 6166(a)(1) only if the estate meets such requirement both with and without the application of subsection (a).

(3)Marital and small transfers

Paragraph (1) shall not apply to any transfer (other than a transfer with respect to a life insurance policy) made during a calendar year to any donee if the decedent was not required by section 6019 (other than by reason of section 6019(2)) to file any gift tax return for such year with respect to transfers to such donee.

(d)Exception

Subsection (a) and paragraph (1) of subsection (c) shall not apply to any bona fide sale for an adequate and full consideration in money or money’s worth.

(e)Treatment of certain transfers from revocable trusts

For purposes of this section and section 2038, any transfer from any portion of a trust during any period that such portion was treated under section 676 as owned by the decedent by reason of a power in the grantor (determined without regard to section 672(e)) shall be treated as a transfer made directly by the decedent.

81 Citing Cases

In particular, they observe that Shepter was legislatively overruled, and they attempt to distinguish Bunting and Necaise on the ground that those cases did not involve inclusions ofgift tax under section 2035(b).

OVERRULED Jean Steinberg, Donor, Petitioner 141 T.C. No. 8 · 2013

The Court finds neither rationale persuasive and appears to overrule McCord, at least to the extent it addresses the former.

The operation ofthe net gift agreement can be distinguished from the operation ofthe New York statutes. The net gift agreement provided an enforcement mechanism to recoup the section 2035(b) estate tax incurred out of the property transferred.

section 2519 deemed transfers lies with the trustees of residual trusts A and B, section 2035 (b) does not apply .

In Murray, unlike the instant case, the obligation was not limited to the “gross-up” tax of (original) section 2035(c), with its preordained inclusion amount and accompanying 3-year window of inclusion (indeed, that provision and the unified gift and estate tax system had yet to be enacted).

- 14 - 2041”.6 Section 2035(c) (unlike section 2035(a), for example), does not describe a “transfer” but merely requires that the gross estate be grossed up by the amount of gift taxes paid on gifts made within 3 years of the decedent’s death.7 The estate suggests that even though section 2035(c) does not explicitly refer to a “transfer”, it neverth

It is true however, as petitionernotes that, pursuant to section 2035(b), decedent's gross estate includes any gift tax payable on decedent's gifts ofLLC units to the nieces b cause those gifts were made within three years ofhis death.25 "The gift tax with respect to the 2002 gift ofLLC units was, in fact, paid by the nieces, i.e.

We hold, therefore, that the Hurfords were not entitled to any discounts because of the FLPs when they calculated the amount of the monthly annuity payments, and so no discounts apply when determining the amount now includable in the estate." C.

Steinberg v. Commissioner 141 T.C. 258 · 2013

nt obligation may be either firmly fixed or conditional, i.e., either absolute or contingent on the occurrence of a future event, a “condition subsequent.” And, it is axiomatic that any conditional liability for the future performance of a present obligation is — to a greater or lesser degree — “speculative.” The issue here, though, is not whether § 2035’s condition subsequent is speculative vel non, but whether it is too speculative to be applicable, a very elastic yardstick indeed.

McCord v. Commissioner 120 T.C. 358 · 2003

If Oliver lived until May 1971, the value of the 1968 Family Trust would no longer have been included in his estate as a gift in contemplation of death under section 2035, significantly reducing his estate tax liability.

The gross estate includes, to the extent provided in various Code sections (including section 2035), the value at the time of a decedent’s death of “all property, real or personal, tangible or intangible, wherever situated.” Sec.

Section 2035 provides in pertinent part: SEC. 2035(a) Inclusion of Gifts Made by Decedent.- -Except as provided in subsection (b), the value of the gross estate shall include the value of all property to the extent of any interest therein of which the decedent has at any time made a transfer, by trust or otherwise, during the 3-year period ending o

Section 2035 provides in pertinent part: SEC. 2035(a) Inclusion of Gifts Made by Decedent.- -Except as provided in subsection (b), the value of the gross estate shall include the value of all property to the extent of any interest therein of which the decedent has at any time made a transfer, by trust or otherwise, during the 3-year period ending o

Under section 2001(e), if a decedent's spouse was the donor of any gift, one-half of which was considered under section 2513 as made by decedent, and the whole amount of such gift is includable in the gross estate of the decedent's spouse by reason of section 2035, then such gift shall not be included in the adjusted taxable gifts of decedent.

Invoking section 2043(a), the Court divides the $10 million into a "dough- nut" and a "doughnut hole." The "doughnut" consists ofthe limited partnership interest allegedly received by the decedent; on the Court's theory, this is pulled back into the gross estate via section 2035 or 2038, and its value then included under section 2033.

Invoking section 2043(a), the Court divides the $10 million into a "dough- nut" and a "doughnut hole." The "doughnut" consists ofthe limited partnership interest allegedly received by the decedent; on the Court's theory, this is pulled back into the gross estate via section 2035 or 2038, and its value then included under section 2033.

It held the following assets with the following market values: - 10 - [*10] Assets Market value Cash $198,453 Marketable equity securities 5,590,778 Marketable municipal bonds 2,386,277 Marketable corporate bonds 30,366 Sovereign debt 6,229 Total 8,212,103 The estate reported on the estate tax return that decedent had made transfers described in section 2035, 2036, 2037, or 2038 during his lifetime.

Section 2035 We now must consider whether decedent's action in reducing the annuity trust term in August 2006 constituted a transfer ofan interest in or relinquishment ofa right with respect to the properties and, ifso, whether section 2035 operates to include the transferred properties in decedent's gross estate notwithstanding such action. Petiti

(Clyde Sr.) transferred to Turner & Co., a family limited partnership, is I GERVED AUG 3 0 2011 - 2 - included in his gross estate under section 2035, 2036, or 2038.¹ We must also decide whether Clyde Sr.

.3 Both parties have offered expert valuation testimony and exhibits to establish the value of the Latina restaurant and 2We note that respondent has not argued on brief that the value of the gifts should be included in decedent’s gross estate under sec. 2035, and we do not decide that issue. 3Although the actual sale may have taken place within a few weeks after Dec. 15, 1992, there is no basis to conclude that the passage of those few weeks would have affected the properties’ value significant

Succession of McCord v. Commissioner 461 F.3d 614 · Cir.
SUCCESSION OF v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE 461 F.3d 614 · Cir.
Estate of Morgens v. Commissioner 678 F.3d 769 · Cir.
Armstrong v. Commissioner 114 T.C. 94 · 2000
Estate of Jalkut v. Commissioner 96 T.C. 675 · 1991
Estate of Marks v. Commissioner 94 T.C. 720 · 1990
Estate of Sachs v. Commissioner 88 T.C. 769 · 1987
Estate of Leder v. Commissioner 89 T.C. 235 · 1987
Estate of Gill v. Commissioner 79 T.C. 437 · 1982
Estate of Stewart v. Commissioner 79 T.C. 1046 · 1982
Estate of Gamble v. Commissioner 69 T.C. 942 · 1978
Estate of Round v. Commissioner 40 T.C. 970 · 1963
Estate of Halbach v. Commissioner 71 T.C. 141 · 1978
Wilson v. Commissioner 56 T.C. 579 · 1971
Estate of Porter v. Commissioner 54 T.C. 1066 · 1970
Estate of Hull v. Commissioner 38 T.C. 512 · 1962
Estate of Green v. Commissioner 64 T.C. 1049 · 1975
Estate of Levin v. Commissioner 90 T.C. 723 · 1988
Estate of Scholl v. Commissioner 88 T.C. 1265 · 1987
Estate of Ceppi v. Commissioner 78 T.C. 320 · 1982
Estate of Drake v. Commissioner 67 T.C. 844 · 1977
Norair v. Commissioner 65 T.C. 942 · 1976
Estate of Lowe v. Commissioner 64 T.C. 663 · 1975
Estate of Hill v. Commissioner 64 T.C. 867 · 1975
Estate of Gerard v. Commissioners 57 T.C. 749 · 1972
Estate of Coleman v. Commissioner 52 T.C. 921 · 1969
Estate of Slater v. Commissioner 93 T.C. 513 · 1989
Poinier v. Commissioner 86 T.C. 478 · 1986
Estate of Clay v. Commissioner 86 T.C. 1266 · 1986
Estate of Lidbury v. Commissioner 84 T.C. 146 · 1985
Estate of Theis v. Commissioner 81 T.C. 741 · 1983
Stern v. Commissioner 77 T.C. 614 · 1981
Estate of Murphy v. Commissioner 71 T.C. 671 · 1979
Cottrell v. Commissioner 72 T.C. 489 · 1979
Estate of Lang v. Commissioner 64 T.C. 404 · 1975
Estate of Zaiger v. Commissioner 64 T.C. 927 · 1975
Estate of Iversen v. Commissioner 65 T.C. 391 · 1975
Kate Froman Trust v. Commissioner 58 T.C. 512 · 1972
Estate of Ford v. Commissioner 53 T.C. 114 · 1969
Estate of Hite v. Commissioner 49 T.C. 580 · 1968
Estate of Byrd v. Commissioner 46 T.C. 25 · 1966
Ingalls v. Commissioner 40 T.C. 751 · 1963
Estate of Lynch v. Commissioner 35 T.C. 142 · 1960
Estate K. Starkey v. United States · Cir.
Estate of Kenneth E. Starkey v. United States 223 F.3d 694 · Cir.